UK Anime Network, UK Anime News, Reviews and Articles
UK Anime Network - Anime Reviews
Peach Girl Vol. 1
Ross Liversidge
Author: Ross Liversidge

Ross founded the UK Anime Network back in 1995 and works in and around the anime industry.

Peach Girl Vol. 1

Distributor
Revelation
Certificate
12
Price
£14.99

Now, I'm fully aware that I'm unlikely to be the target audience for this title (28, male) so I drafted in the services of one Rachel Mei Liang (20, female, cute).

The Peach Girl manga is one of the better selling girls titles out there, and features a feisty, light-haired, dark skinned girl named Momo, who sees her unusual looks as a major hindrance to her social standing (her unique skin tone and light coloured hair makes her look like a "Ganguro" girl, a term used to describe girls obsessed with fashion and considered "easy"), and a major barrier between her and secret crush Toji.

This situation is made far worse by her so-called "friend" Sae, a backstabbing, underhanded social climber with no real personality of her own and a penchant for putting down others in order to build herself up. We've all seen one of these odious creatures at some time in our lives, and it makes it all the more frustrating to watch her.

Now the main problem I have with this series is not the sub-par animation or the teen angst. It's not even the slightly cliched premise. The problem I have is with the writing, which on this disk is simply appalling. We chose to watch the sub after 2 minutes of the screechy dub, and despite the extra attention required to read the subtitles, I failed to find anything to hold my interest. Momo was an erratic lead - one moment she was all fire and passion, the next she was taking all sorts of crap from Sae and not uttering a word. The situations in the series were pure soap-opera fluff, with situations and misunderstandings engineered by Sae that were so see-through that I wanted to shout at the TV and slap every character in the show.

That is, until my brain imploded and I was left struggling to stay awake. At 3 in the afternoon.

Turning to Rachel for a second opinion, I discovered that she'd succumbed to tedium and taken the only sane way out. By falling asleep.

There may be some who like this - after all plenty of people watch EastEnders, which I'd place on a par with Peach Girl in terms of inventive writing. There are better titles out there, and its a shame that one of the few series aimed at girls should fall on its face in such a fashion.


Extras:

Plentiful:

  • Actor/Director Commentary
  • Interview with Saeko Chiba (Momo)
  • Trailers
  • Textless Songs

The special addition comes with a little pink bag and volume 1 of the manga.


3
Almost painful to watch.
COMMENT AND DISCUSS
blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest Reviews:

posted by Robert Mullarkey on 16 Jul 2019
posted by Dawffyd on 05 Jul 2019
posted by Ross Liversidge on 13 Jun 2019
posted by Dan Barnett on 06 Jun 2019
posted by Tom McIlroy on 24 May 2019
posted by Ross Liversidge on 20 May 2019
posted by Robert Mullarkey on 17 May 2019
posted by Dan Barnett on 16 May 2019